Back to 2011 Program
Trends in Surgical Management of Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia
Nora Lee1, Hui Xue2, Lori B. Lerner3 1Boston University Medical Center, Boston, MA;2Harvard University, Boston, MA;3Boston Veterans Affairs Hospital, Boston, MA
Introduction Surgical management of benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) has evolved, including techniques that can be used with the growing population of anticoagulated patients. We evaluated current trends in procedure utilization amongst American urologists. Methods A 90-item on-line survey was sent via email to: American Urological Association; Veterans Administration; Society for Government Service Urologists; Endourological Society. Data concerning utilization of 12 BPH surgical techniques were analyzed and compared to surgeons' demographics using categorical data analysis. Results 600 urologists replied; 570 currently perform BPH surgery. Table 1 shows procedure utilization. Urologists' age, year of residency completion, and region of country had no influence on technique utilization, except in Northeastern (less monopolar TURP, p=0.04) and New York Sections (less PVP, p=0.01). Academic versus private settings were no different other than RP and Button which occur more often in academics (RP 7% vs 2%, button TURP 28% vs 21%). High volume surgeons are more likely to perform monopolar and bipolar TURP, whereas low volume surgeons are more likely to perform PVP, HoLAP, and HoLEP. Conclusions Change in technology has altered urologists' surgical approach to BPH. OP and monopolar TURP are still the most utilized procedures, however, bipolar and laser therapies are becoming more common. Lower volume surgeons appear to perform more laser techniques. Academic programs did not influence preference in technique except with robotic surgery and Button. Table 1. | | Surgical technique | Percentage of respondents who utilize the procedure | Open prostatectomy | 78% | Monopolar transurethral resection of prostate (TURP) | 73% | Photoselective vaporization (PVP) | 58% | TURis button TURP | 24% | Bipolar TURP | 20% | Holmium laser ablation of prostate (HoLAP) | 18% | Holmium laser enucleation of prostate (HoLEP) | 8% | Diode laser vaporization | 8% | Thulium laser ablation of prostate | 4% | Robotic simple prostatectomy | 3% | Laparoscopic simple prostatectomy | 1% | Thulium laser enucleation of prostate | 0% |
Back to 2011 Program
|